Loading Gee Radio...

OFF AIR Gee Radio
Published On: October 19, 2026 Categories: Crime & Court

Paul Mackenzie and 28 Others Convicted of 191 Murders in Shakahola Tragedy

The High Court has found the controversial preacher and his co-accused guilty over the deaths of 190 children and one adult, in a landmark case that has renewed calls for stronger safeguards against religious extremism in Kenya.

Paul Mackenzie and 28 Others Convicted of 191 Murders in Shakahola Tragedy

0 likes

A court ruling in one of Kenya’s most disturbing criminal cases has brought a major turning point in the Shakahola tragedy, with self-proclaimed preacher Paul Nthenge Mackenzie and 28 co-accused found guilty of 191 counts of murder.

The High Court delivered the judgment on Monday, October 19, 2026, holding the accused criminally responsible for the deaths of 190 children and one adult linked to the events in Shakahola Forest, Kilifi County.

The case centres on a religious movement led by Mackenzie, whose followers were allegedly persuaded to undertake extreme fasting in the belief that starving themselves would allow them to meet Jesus. The court found that the deaths were not simply the result of voluntary religious practices, but were connected to an organised system of radicalisation, coercion and enforced fasting.

The verdict marks a significant development in a case that has shocked Kenya and raised difficult questions about religious freedom, child protection and the responsibility of authorities to intervene when religious teachings put lives at risk.

How religious teachings allegedly led to mass deaths

During the trial, the prosecution presented evidence linking Mackenzie’s teachings to the isolation and eventual deaths of followers who had settled in Shakahola Forest.

According to the court’s findings, the belief system promoted by the Good News International Ministries discouraged followers from pursuing formal education, seeking modern medical treatment and trusting government institutions. Members were also encouraged to separate themselves from wider society and relocate to the forest.

The court identified a pattern of radicalisation that culminated in the enforcement of fatal fasting.

Investigators and witnesses described how followers were allegedly instructed to stop eating as part of a religious process intended to prepare them to meet Jesus. Children were reportedly expected to die first, followed by young people, women and men, with Mackenzie and his family expected to die last.

The prosecution also presented testimony indicating that some followers who resisted the instructions faced violence, confinement and other forms of coercion.

These accounts became central to the case, particularly the question of whether the victims had freely chosen to fast or had been subjected to a system that denied them food, freedom and protection.

Children were among the most vulnerable victims

The deaths of children formed the most painful part of the case, with survivors describing the conditions they experienced while living in the forest.

According to evidence presented in court, some children were denied food and water even when supplies were available. Others reportedly watched their brothers and sisters deteriorate and die.

The court rejected the argument that the children had voluntarily participated in the fasting regime. Justice Diana Kavedza held that children could not legally consent to being starved to death in pursuit of religious beliefs.

The judgment also addressed the responsibilities of parents and guardians, making clear that parental authority does not extend to practices that deliberately endanger a child’s life.

The court’s position reinforces a fundamental principle: religious belief does not remove the legal obligation to protect children from abuse, neglect or life-threatening treatment.

Forensic evidence revealed the scale of the tragedy

The Shakahola investigation exposed the extent of the deaths after authorities began recovering bodies from shallow graves in the forest.

Forensic examinations established starvation as the cause of death in dozens of cases. Other victims died from asphyxia, neck compression and traumatic head injuries, according to the evidence described during the proceedings.

In many other cases, advanced decomposition made it difficult for forensic experts to establish the precise cause of death.

The court nevertheless found that the wider evidence, including survivor testimony, the reported fasting practices and the circumstances surrounding the graves, supported the prosecution’s case.

Investigators also heard accounts of burials being referred to as harusi, the Swahili word for weddings, while deceased followers were described as shujaa wa imani, or heroes of faith.

Evidence further indicated that some graves were concealed or flattened to prevent bodies from being discovered.

The findings helped the court assess not only how the victims died, but also whether the accused had participated in a coordinated effort to enforce the fasting regime and conceal its consequences.

An organised network of control

The judgment also examined the roles played by individuals around Mackenzie and how the group allegedly maintained control over its members.

Among those convicted was Smart Deri Mwakalama, identified as the church’s secretary and Mackenzie’s second-in-command. The court found that he had participated in activities including transporting followers, relaying instructions and supervising burials.

Stephen Sanga Muye, identified as the group’s head of security, was also linked to assaults, grave digging and the reburial of victims.

Other accused persons were associated with guarding fasting areas, preventing followers from escaping, withholding food and water, and concealing graves.

The court found that Mackenzie had demonstrated an intention to cause death through his directives, while those who knowingly enforced the fasting regime understood the likely consequences of their actions.

The ruling also addressed the legal implications of the group’s alleged extremist belief system, including its relationship with provisions of Kenya’s anti-terrorism legislation.

How the Shakahola tragedy came to light

The case began attracting national attention in March 2023 after concerns were reported about children allegedly being starved in Shakahola.

The report prompted investigations and a wider operation involving multiple government agencies. Authorities subsequently discovered numerous shallow graves across the forest.

Between April and July 2023, investigators recovered 429 bodies during four phases of exhumation, according to the figures presented in the supplied case account. The 191 murder counts addressed in Monday’s judgment relate to a specific group of victims from the wider tragedy.

Investigations revealed that some followers had abandoned their homes, sold property, left employment and withdrawn their children from school before moving to the forest.

The settlement was divided into villages with biblical names, including Galilaya, Judea, Bethlehem, Sidoni and Samaria.

For many families, the discovery of the graves brought devastating news about relatives whose whereabouts had been unknown for months.

A wider debate about religious accountability

The Shakahola tragedy has exposed the risks that arise when religious authority is used to isolate followers, discourage access to essential services and justify practices that threaten human life.

It has also raised questions about how authorities can identify and respond to dangerous religious movements without undermining the constitutional right to freedom of religion.

For Kenya, the challenge extends beyond the prosecution of individuals. It includes protecting children, supporting survivors and affected families, and ensuring that warning signs of coercion and abuse are taken seriously.

Any response must distinguish between the lawful practice of religion and conduct that involves violence, exploitation, unlawful confinement or the deliberate endangerment of vulnerable people.

The court’s findings place individual criminal responsibility at the centre of the Shakahola case. They also underline the importance of effective investigations and timely intervention when people are being harmed.

What happens next?

Mackenzie and his co-accused face separate legal proceedings involving other allegations, including manslaughter and terrorism-related offences. The murder conviction does not, by itself, determine the outcome of those separate cases.

According to the information provided for this report, sentencing in the murder case is expected on November 6, 2026.

The judgment is a major development in a tragedy that claimed hundreds of lives and left families and communities searching for answers.

For the relatives of the victims, the conviction represents a significant legal milestone, although no court decision can reverse the loss of their loved ones.

The Shakahola case remains a stark reminder of the consequences of unchecked religious manipulation and the importance of protecting human life, particularly when children and other vulnerable people are placed at risk.

Share

Share this story

Choose a platform or copy the link